Autumn Hot Toddy

Autumn is the perfect time to sip a hot beverage. I wanted to give a classic Hot Toddy a fall twist and I think I pulled it off.

Sit back and sip a hot toddy made with applejack, orange and hot chai sweetened with maple syrup perfect for a cool autumn day

How to Make Hot Toddies

You start with tea and add different flavors with fruit, herbs & spices, sweetener and the best part booze! You can really mix it up, for example, when I’m under the weather I love to make a hot toddy with chamomile tea.

For this particular recipe I really wanted to pull in some classic fall spices so I grabbed a container of Chai. It’s a mix of black tea with cloves, cinnamon and other spices. If you’re not into the super spicy flavors you can make this with plain black tea and it’s still great.

Sit back and sip a hot toddy made with applejack, orange and hot chai sweetened with maple syrup perfect for a cool autumn day

I used loose tea but it’s easier to grab some in bags if you’re out and about. I used my manatee infuser along with my handy electric kettle to make 1.5 cups of tea. If you’re a tea drinker do yourself a favor and get an electric kettle! It takes like 15 seconds to get hot water.

Fresh Citrus

Most hot toddies are made with lemon. But I’m a rebel! And I like apple and orange together. So I grabbed a bag of oranges. Cut a slice out right through the middle for your garnish and set it aside.

Grab a citrus press and squeeze the rest of the orange into the cup. It seems counter intuitive but when you use a hand press you place the cut side down. The back will press it forward and basically turn it inside out.  You can also use your hands like a raccoon.

Herbs & Spices

This time we’re relying on the tea for most of our special flavor additions. You really can’t go wrong if you toss in a cinnamon stick or some fresh ginger if you have it on hand.


Honey is the OG sweetener of choice for hot toddies. It’s sweet, tasty and it had all that medical goodness that let’s you pretend you’re drinking medicine and not a giant mug of alcohol ๐Ÿ˜‰

We’re gonna swap that out for some maple syrup. REAL maple syrup. If you’re gonna use the fake stuff you a. should be ashamed of yourself and b. skip it. I’m from upstate NY where we take maple everything very seriously.

The Booze

You may be wondering where the apple comes in. In the liquor of course! I grabbed a bottle of Laird’s Applejack.

Applejack is one of those old school alcohols you might not be that familiar with. It was popular in the colonial era because it was easy to make.

Instead of heating to distill the alcohol it was frozen. The alcohol didn’t freeze but the water did, so as the ice was removed the alcohol content of the liquor went up.

You probably won’t find that kind of Applejack today. Applejack in general fell out of favor in the mid-19th centry thanks to cheap grain and metal stills.

Sit back and sip a hot toddy made with applejack, orange and hot chai sweetened with maple syrup perfect for a cool autumn day

But like everything else old it’s making a comeback! A delicious comeback, which is the best kind. If you’re looking to snag a bottle check the brandy section for a bottle of Laird’s. They’ve traded in the freezing method for evaporation distillation but it’s still full of apple flavor and great for the fall.

Laird’s Applejakc is a blend of apple brandy and neutral grain alcohol. I used 2 ounces for my hot toddy. If you’re not the measturing type just pour it in until you’re out of room ๐Ÿ˜‰

I hope you enjoyed our impromptu history lesson. I hated history classes in school, maybe I just needed more jacked apple brandy? On second thought that’s not a great idea..

If you don’t have Applejack on hand: use any whiskey & toss in some apple cider. You’ll end up with a strong and autumn flavored drink all the same.

Actually, toss in the apple cider even if you do have applejack. I’m counting down the days until the local cider mills open (along with maple syrup I’m also a cider snob) and it seems like time is going so slowly.

The harsh truth. This isn’t really that strongly apple flavored. Instead all the flavors blend together to taste like autumn in a mug.

Don’t forget to PIN this to your Autumn and Cocktails Boards!

clear glass mug filled with Applejack and Ornage Hot toddy with Manatea tea strainer and bottles of maple syrup and applejack in the background on an aged white wooden surface wit h two crossed cinnamon sticks

Autumn Hot Toddy

Yield: 1

Sit back and sip a hot toddy made with applejack, orange and hot chai perfect for a cool autumn day


  • 1 Orange
  • 1-1.5 cup Steeped Hot Chai
  • 2 oz Applejack
  • Maple Syrup


  1. Cut a slice from the center of the orange, reserve for garnish. Juice the remaining orange into the serving glass. 
  2. Pour in Appljack and hot tea
  3. Sweeten with maple syrup to taste
  4. Serve hot 
Check out my Autumn Page for more fall recipes or start here:

milk and pumpkin pie cream liqueur in a large clear coffee mug on a natural tile with a bottle of Fulton's Harvest Pumpkin Pie Cream Liqueur,

glass pitcher filled with sliced pears and white wine pear sangria with a bottle of chardonnay, a pear and a wine bottle opener


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *